The Four Horsemen: Understanding Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, and Stonewalling in Relationships
Written by: Ralph B
Navigating the ups and downs of a relationship can sometimes feel like riding a rollercoaster. One moment, you're on cloud nine, and the next, you're in the midst of a heated argument. While conflict is a natural part of any partnership, certain behaviors can spell trouble for the long-term health of your relationship. Enter the "Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse" of relationships: criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling.

In the world of relationship psychology, these four behaviors are known as the "Four Horsemen," a term coined by Dr. John Gottman, a renowned psychologist and relationship expert. According to Gottman's research, these destructive behaviors can erode the foundation of a relationship if left unchecked. So, let's take a closer look at each of the Four Horsemen and learn how to recognize and address them in our own relationships.

1. Criticism

Criticism rears its ugly head when one partner attacks the other's character or personality rather than addressing a specific behavior or issue. Instead of expressing a complaint in a constructive manner, criticism takes on a more accusatory tone, often leading to feelings of defensiveness and resentment.

For example, imagine a scenario where one partner forgets to take out the trash. Instead of calmly addressing the issue, the other partner lashes out, saying something like, "You're so lazy and irresponsible! I can't believe I have to remind you to do simple tasks like taking out the trash."

In this case, the criticism is not focused on the specific behavior (forgetting to take out the trash) but rather attacks the individual's character (calling them lazy and irresponsible). This type of communication only serves to escalate conflict and damage the relationship.

2. Contempt

Contempt takes criticism to a whole new level by adding a dose of superiority and disrespect into the mix. It often manifests in the form of sarcasm, mockery, or disdain towards your partner. Contempt is toxic because it conveys a fundamental lack of respect and admiration for your partner, which can quickly corrode the emotional bond between you.

For instance, imagine a scenario where one partner expresses their excitement about a new hobby they want to pursue. Instead of offering support and encouragement, the other partner responds with contempt, saying something like, "Oh great, another one of your ridiculous ideas. Like you'll actually stick with it this time."

This kind of contemptuous behavior not only undermines your partner's confidence but also creates a toxic atmosphere of hostility and resentment in the relationship. Over time, repeated expressions of contempt can lead to irreparable damage and even the breakdown of the partnership.

3. Defensiveness

When faced with criticism or contempt, it's natural to want to defend ourselves and protect our ego. However, defensiveness can quickly escalate a conflict and prevent productive communication from taking place. Instead of taking responsibility for our actions or acknowledging our partner's concerns, defensive responses often involve shifting blame, making excuses, or playing the victim.

For example, imagine a scenario where one partner expresses frustration about feeling neglected in the relationship. Instead of listening to their concerns and taking steps to address them, the other partner responds defensively, saying something like, "Well, if you weren't always nagging me, maybe I'd feel more inclined to spend time with you."

By deflecting responsibility and turning the tables on their partner, the defensive partner fails to address the underlying issues in the relationship, leading to further resentment and discord.

4. Stonewalling

Stonewalling is perhaps the most destructive of the Four Horsemen, as it involves shutting down communication entirely in the face of conflict. When a partner stonewalls, they withdraw from the interaction, refusing to engage or respond to their partner's attempts to communicate. This behavior leaves the other partner feeling frustrated, ignored, and invalidated, ultimately leading to a breakdown in communication and emotional connection.

For instance, imagine a scenario where one partner attempts to initiate a conversation about a recurring issue in the relationship. Instead of engaging in dialogue, the other partner stonewalls, giving their partner the silent treatment and refusing to acknowledge their concerns.

This lack of communication not only prevents resolution of the underlying issues but also creates a sense of isolation and disconnection between partners. Over time, repeated instances of stonewalling can lead to deep-seated resentment and emotional detachment, further undermining the health of the relationship.

Recognizing and Addressing the Four Horsemen

Now that we've identified the Four Horsemen, let's talk about how to recognize and address them in our own relationships. The first step is awareness—being able to recognize when these destructive behaviors are present in our interactions with our partners. Once we've identified the Four Horsemen, we can take proactive steps to address them and cultivate healthier patterns of communication.

Instead of resorting to criticism, contempt, defensiveness, or stonewalling, strive to approach conflict with empathy, understanding, and respect. Practice active listening, validate your partner's feelings, and focus on finding solutions rather than assigning blame. By fostering a culture of mutual respect and open communication, you can strengthen the foundation of your relationship and weather the inevitable storms that come your way.

In conclusion, the Four Horsemen—criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling—are powerful forces that can wreak havoc on our relationships if left unchecked. By recognizing these destructive behaviors and taking proactive steps to address them, we can cultivate healthier, more fulfilling partnerships built on a foundation of trust, respect, and mutual understanding. So, saddle up, fellow riders, and let's work together to keep the Four Horsemen at bay and ride off into the sunset of lasting love and happiness.
 Ralph B 

Ralph B. is the founder of "Help for Men" as well as "Dad Starting Over". He is also the author of four books:

Ralph has coached and counseled over 1,000 men from around the world. 

THE HFM
BROTHERHOOD

Join our private men's group with hundreds of members from around the world. Lots of great benefits including private discussion forums, live meetings, discounts on products, meetups, conferences, and more!
Join our private men's group with hundreds of members from around the world. Lots of great benefits including private discussion forums, live meetings, discounts on products, meetups, conferences, and more!
Unlock Expert Advise, Exclusive
Content, and Practical Tips Delivered
Directly to Your Inbox.
settings
arrow_forward
SUBSCRIBE
settings
arrow_forward
SUBSCRIBE
[bot_catcher]